Gulf Restoration Network

IS SOMETHING FISHY GOING ON WITH MENHADEN? Blog - Fish and Bycatch Wednesday, 25 February 2009 11:02

Dr. Vernon Asper, who chairs the commission, has said he agrees more study needs to be done, but he typically doesn’t vote under the commission’s rules unless there is a tie. On this issue, he should.

He should be joined by commission member Shelby Drummond, who represents recreational fishermen. Drummond has said he is willing “to go along with the science,” so he should support a scientific study of the situation.

At least two pressing questions must be answered:

1. Are so many menhaden being caught that it could wreck the food supply for other fish that eat them?

2. Are the nets used to catch menhaden pulling up too many other species as bycatch?

These are legitimate issues and the commission does not appear to have reliable information to satisfy those concerned about either one.