|
Over the past couple of days, I have gotten several questions about dispersants that are being used to combat the ever-growing oil slick in the Gulf: What do dispersants do? Are they effective? Are they toxic? What happens to the oil? I will be the first to admit that I cannot come close to answering all of these questions, but based on the research I have done here are my impressions:
Â
Photo from Associated Press
However, there is a major trade-off involved. The oil that is “dispersed” from the surface ultimate ends up in the water column, and at the bottom of the oceans – endangering the marine life that resides in these areas. The most commonly used dispersant, Corexit 9500, can be toxic to crustaceans at relatively low levels and there are significant concerns about what effect the combined oil and dispersants will have on bottom-dwelling critters, as well as larval fish.
There is a remarkable lack of study on how dispersants affect the water column, and wildlife but we do know that the oil that is “dispersed” is likely to remain hidden below the Gulf for some time to come. It’s is difficult to say whether or not dispersants should be used and under what circumstances, but it is obvious that we do not know enough about these dispersants. This is why I suggest that independent scientists, university scientists, and agencies, such as NOAA and EPA, begin studying these dispersed oils in the Gulf immediately to ensure that we are not making an ill-fated tradeoff, and so if a big spill happens again, we will be better prepared.
To read my more in-depth analysis, go here .
There has been a bit of coverage regarding dispersants over the past couple of days, I would suggest taking a look at what the Lower Mississippi Riverkeeper, and NRDC have been posting on the issue. Also check out recent articles in the New York Times and Grist.
Matt is Water Resources Program Director for GRN
|
|
BP's Oil Drilling Disaster
Recent Posts

|
Reports from the Defend the Gulf Movie Screenings that happened around the country this weekend are Written by Dan Favre Wednesday, 01 September 2010
|
|
This week, the New York Times green blog covered the Gulf restoration planning process, announced Written by Aaron Viles Saturday, 28 August 2010
|
|
On Wednesday, August 25, I attended the second public meeting of the National Commission on Written by Johanna F. Polsenberg Thursday, 26 August 2010
|
|
Support for the Gulf coast continues to grow!! Companies, individuals, and kids from across Written by Briana Kerstein Wednesday, 25 August 2010
|
|
On the 23rd, BP once again asked the Corps of Engineers for an Emergency Permit to “surf wash” Written by Matt Rota Wednesday, 25 August 2010 |
|
To mark the five-year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina -- and in response to the BP Oil Written by Aaron Viles Tuesday, 24 August 2010 |
|
We just recieved this update from St. Bernard Parish officials.
Large fish kill found at the mouth Written by Aaron Viles Monday, 23 August 2010 |
|
